Home / Compare / Butternut Box Fresh Meals vs Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food

Butternut Box Fresh Meals vs Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food

Detailed comparison of Butternut Box Fresh Meals and Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food. Compare specs, price, pros & cons to find which is best for you.

Quick Verdict

The Butternut Box Fresh Meals leads with a 4.9★ rating (4,560 reviews). Its standout strength: human-grade ingredients. The Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food counters with natural ingredients. Price difference: £29.01.

Full Spec Comparison

Butternut Box

Butternut Box Fresh Meals

£72
VS
Lily's Kitchen

Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food

£42.99Best Pick
Rating
★★★★4.9
★★★★4.6
Reviews
4,560
6,780
Brand
Butternut Box
Lily's Kitchen
type
Fresh/Cooked
Dry Kibble
protein
High
26%
delivery
Subscription
—
ingredients
Human-grade meat and veg
Fresh chicken, sweet potato, peas
portions
Pre-portioned
—
weight
—
7kg
age
—
Adult
Pros
Human-grade ingredientsPre-portioned mealsPersonalised plans
Natural ingredientsNo artificial additivesUK made
Cons
Requires freezer spaceExpensive monthly cost
Smaller bag sizeStrong smell

View Deals

AI RecommendedTop Rated-12%Prime Deal
Butternut BoxAI VerifiedAI Verified

Butternut Box Fresh Meals

★★★★½4.9(4,560 reviews)
from£72RRP £82Save £102 retailers

Human-grade ingredients

typeFresh/Cooked
proteinHigh
deliverySubscription
Human-grade ingredientsPre-portioned meals
Requires freezer space
Affiliate link
Top Rated
Lily's KitchenAI VerifiedAI Verified

Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food

★★★★½4.6(6,780 reviews)
from£42.99$52.99
weight7kg
protein26%
typeDry Kibble
Natural ingredientsNo artificial additives
Smaller bag size
Affiliate link

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better: Butternut Box Fresh Meals or Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food?

The Butternut Box Fresh Meals edges ahead with a 4.9★ rating vs 4.6★.Human-grade ingredients. However, the Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food wins on natural ingredients. Your best choice depends on whether you prioritise premium feeding or natural diet.

Is the Butternut Box Fresh Meals worth it over the Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food?

The Butternut Box Fresh Meals costs £72 while the Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food is £42.99. The Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food offers better value for money. Both are excellent for premium feeding and fussy eaters.

Butternut Box Fresh Meals vs Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food — which should I buy in 2026?

Choose the Butternut Box Fresh Meals if you prioritise human-grade ingredients. Choose the Lily's Kitchen Proper Dog Food if you prioritise natural ingredients. Both are top-rated in the dog-food category.

Still not sure? Ask our AI for a personalised recommendation.

Ask AIPickPet